Our Program and Focus Areas
The Regional Monitoring Program for Water Quality in San Francisco Bay (RMP) is SFEI’s largest program. It provides the information that regulators and decision-makers need to manage the Bay effectively. The RMP is an innovative collaborative effort between SFEI, the Regional Water Quality Control Board, and the regulated discharger community.
An innovative partnership
The RMP has combined shared financial support, direction, and participation by regulatory agencies and the regulated community in a model of collective responsibility. The RMP has established a climate of cooperation and a commitment to participation among a wide range of regulators, dischargers, industry representatives, non-governmental agencies, and scientists. The RMP provides an open forum for interested parties to discuss contaminant issues facing the Bay.
An adaptive, long term program of study in support of management
Stable funding has enabled the RMP to develop long-term plans. In addition, Special Studies provide an opportunity to adapt to changing management priorities and advances in scientific understanding. RMP committees and workgroups meet regularly to keep the Program efficient, focused on the highest priority issues, and to ensure that RMP science is sound. The RMP has continually improved since its inception in 1993.
A high quality body of knowledge
The RMP has produced a world-class dataset on estuarine contaminants. Monitoring performed in the RMP determines spatial patterns and long-term trends in contamination through sampling of water, sediment, bivalves, bird eggs, and fish, and evaluates toxic effects on sensitive organisms and chemical loading to the Bay. The Program combines RMP data with data from other sources to provide for comprehensive assessment of chemical contamination in the Bay.
A portal to information about contamination in San Francisco Bay
The RMP provides information targeted at the highest priority questions faced by managers of the Bay. The RMP produces summary reports (Pulse of The Bay and RMP Update), technical reports that document specific studies and synthesize information from diverse sources, as well as journal publications that disseminate RMP results to the world’s scientific community. The RMP website provides access to RMP data, information products, and links to other sources of information about water quality in San Francisco Bay.
Events and Meeting Materials
Focus areas covered by the RMP are primarily addressed by the six workgroups: Emerging Contaminants (ECWG); Exposure and Effects (EEWG); Sources, Pathways and Loadings (SPLWG); PCBs; Selenium; and Dioxin. Workgroups consist of scientists who are currently studying the Bay, invited scientists who are nationally recognized experts in their field, and federal and state regulators. Each workgroup meets one to three times a year to address issues concerning the planning and implementation of RMP Special Studies and relevant elements of Status and Trends monitoring.
RMP "strategy teams" provide a forum for focus on specific interests to the program. The strategy teams are composed of stakeholder groups, which meet as needed to develop long-term RMP study plans for addressing high priority topics. To date, the RMP has developed strategies pertaining to mercury, PCBs, dioxins, small tributary loads, forecasting, and sport fish. The RMP also participates in the San Francisco Bay Nutrient Science and Management Strategy, which is developing the science needed for informed decisions about managing nutrient loads and maintaining beneficial uses within the Bay.
Activities of the workgroups, and technical content of the program as a whole, are overseen by the Technical Review Committee. The Steering Committee determines the overall budget, allocates program funds, tracks progress, and provides direction to the Program from a manager's perspective.
- Bay RMP Charter
- 2020 Detailed Workplan & Budget
- 2021 Multi-Year Plan
- 2020 Multi-Year Plan
- 2019 Multi-Year Plan
Events and Meeting Materials
The RMP has a long-term Status and Trends Monitoring Program that began in 1993. The monitoring design has evolved over time and currently consists of:
- Contaminants in ambient Bay water (every 2 years)
- Contaminants in ambient Bay sediment (every 4 years)
- Contaminants in bivalve tissue (every 2 years)
- Contaminants in sport fish tissue (every 5 years)
- Contaminants in cormorant and tern egg tissue (every 3 years)
- Long-term hydrographic and sediment transport studies by the U.S. Geological Survey (annually)
Status & Trends Monitoring Projects
In 1997, the RMP underwent a 5-year program review which helped to develop a revised set of RMP objectives including a new objective: “Describe general sources and loading of contamination to the Estuary” (Bernstein and O’Connor, 1997). The goal was to create a functional connection between the RMP and efforts to identify, eliminate, and prevent sources of pollution that influence the Bay. Guided by the new objective, the Sources, Pathways, and Loading Workgroup (SPLWG) was formed in early 1999 to produce recommendations for collection, interpretation, and synthesis of data on general sources and loading of trace contaminants to the Estuary. The first SPLWG recommendations were described in the first “Technical Report of the Sources Pathways and Loadings Workgroup” (Davis et al., 1999). Since that time the SPLWG has continued to provide management context and technical review on a series of desktop and field studies that largely followed the recommendations of Davis et al. (1999). The SPLWG ensures that the projects and products are relevant and help to answer ever developing management questions in the context of TMDLs and attainment of water quality standards.
In addition to it's other work, the SPLWG also oversees the Small Tributaries Loading Strategy (STLS) project. The STLS focuses on loadings from small tributaries (the rivers, creeks, and storm drains that enter the Bay downstream of Chipps Island), in coordination with the Municipal Regional Permit for Stormwater (MRP).
The scientific advisory panel consists of internationally known experts in this field including:
- Dr. Barbara Mahler, US Geological Survey
- Dr. Dan Cain, US Geological Survey
- Dr. Tom Jobes
- Dr. Dan Wang, CA Department of Pesticide Regulation
Lead Scientist: Lester McKee
For further information, please contact Lester McKee at: ph 510-746-7363 or [email protected].
The Bay RMP fills critical science needs to assist managers in their goal of reducing harmful emerging contaminants in the Bay. Emerging contaminants are not currently regulated or commonly monitored, yet may pose significant ecological or human health risks.
A global leader in this field, the Bay RMP has developed an emerging contaminants strategy that guides decisions on monitoring and management. Early identification of problem pollutants and quick action to prevent their spread is an optimal and cost-effective strategy for protecting water quality. This is especially true in an ecosystem like the Bay, which can act as a long-term trap for persistent contaminants, with recovery taking decades or centuries when contamination is extensive.
Diligent surveillance using targeted and broadscan (non-targeted) techniques has identified four emerging contaminants or classes of moderate concern for the Bay:
- PFOS, a stain and water repellent
- PFOA and related long-chain perfluorocarboxylates, previously used in fire-fighting foams and to make non-stick coatings
- Fipronil, an insecticide
- Alkylphenols and alkylphenol ethoxylates, surfactant ingredients in detergents and many other products
- Imidacloprid, neonicotinoid insectiside
- Organo-phosphate Esters, flame retardants
- Bisphenols, commonly found in plastic products
PFOS, PFOA, and other poly- and perfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a particular focus of the RMP, and the subject of a recently completed synthesis and strategy document. Flame retardants known as PBDEs were once moderate concerns for the Bay, but bans and phase-outs reduced contamination to levels of low concern. Many other contaminants have been monitored in the Bay and found to be of low concern as well. A multitude of emerging contaminants fall into a final category of possible concern, where uncertainty in our knowledge of toxicity prevents an evaluation of risk. See the RMP's CEC Strategy (2017 Revision), the 2020 Strategy Update, and the 2019 Pulse of the Bay for more information.
The scientific advisory panel for the Bay RMP Emerging Contaminants Workgroup (ECWG) consists of internationally respected experts:
- Dr. Bill Arnold, University of Minnesota
- Dr. Miriam Diamond, University of Toronto
- Dr. Lee Ferguson, Duke University
- Dr. Dan Villinueve, US EPA
- Dr. Derek Muir, Environment and Climate Change Canada
- Dr. Heather Stapleton, Duke University
Green chemistry is a critical tool in efforts to prevent the pollution of our environment. By selecting safer chemicals and processes for making consumer products, we limit contamination that can adversely impact the health of the Bay and other aquatic ecosystems. We can also reduce expensive monitoring, remediation, and management actions.
SFEI provides applied science that policymakers and managers need to make well-informed decisions. Our green chemistry research fills critical needs of state and local agencies involved in the effort to guide manufacturers towards safer choices. A key focus is advising California's unique green chemistry approach, taking shape through the Safer Consumer Products Regulations. Pollution prevention measures informed by SFEI's green chemistry studies play a notable role in supporting and protecting healthy aquatic ecosystems through independent science.
Recent highlights of SFEI’s green chemistry focus area:
- January 2017: Senior scientist Dr. Rebecca Sutton presents information on key contaminants associated with aquatic impacts to the Department of Toxic Substances Control to inform implementation of the Safer Consumer Products Regulations.
- January 2017: A letter to Health Canada regarding proposed regulations on the pesticide imidacloprid highlights new findings relevant to spot-on flea control products.
- January 2016: Dr. Sutton speaks at a California legislative science-policy briefing on ocean and freshwater plastic pollution.
- May 2015: Dr. Sutton provides testimony to California's Proposition 65 Scientific Advisory Board regarding the reproductive toxicity of bisphenol A. Board members unanimously list bisphenol A as a reproductive toxicant.
- February 2015: Dr. Sutton presents new data on flame retardants in San Francisco Bay as part of the 2015 Flame Retardants Dilemma symposium.
- January 2014: Dr. Sutton is appointed to state Green Ribbon Science Panel to inform the implementation of the Safer Consumer Products Regulations. The appointment is renewed in 2017.
Lead Scientist: Rebecca Sutton, Ph.D.
PCBs are a pollutant of high concern in San Francisco Bay. Additionally, the bay was placed on the State of California’s 303(d) list of impaired waterways in 1998 as a result of elevated concentrations of dioxins and furans (commonly referred to as only ‘dioxin’) in fish. The PCB & Dioxin strategy ensures that the RMP is providing the information needed to support the development of appropriate effluent limits for municipal and industrial discharges and find remedies to the Bay’s PCB problem. The upcoming management decisions include the next iteration (2020-2021) of the PCB TMDL and identifying the best options for management actions to reduce PCB impairment. Our understanding of dioxin in the Bay has improved due to special studies conducted over the past decade. Although the available information suggests progress will be slow toward Bay-wide reductions in concentrations in fish and resulting health risks to humans and wildlife, similar to PCBs, there may be localized opportunities to effect change at select, more highly impacted, sites.
The scientific advisory panel for the Bay RMP PCBs & Dioxin Workgroup consists of:
Dr. Frank Gobas, Simon Fraser University
Lead Scientist: Jay Davis
For more information, please contact Jay Davis at: 510-746-7368 or [email protected].
*This workgroup is currently dormant due to the implementation of long-term monitoring in North San Francisco Bay*
The Bay RMP Selenium Workgroup was established in 2014 at the direction of the RMP Steering Committee. San Francisco Bay was listed under section 303(d) of the Clean Water Act as impaired for selenium in 1998. The listing was because elevated concentrations found in biota often exceed levels that can cause potential reproductive impacts in white sturgeon and are often higher than levels considered safe for fish and other wildlife species in the estuary. The problem has been somewhat exacerbated by the introduction of the Asian clam (Corbula amurensis) into the Bay in 1986. This non-native clam is a prodigious filter-feeder, and by consuming large quantities of selenium-laden particles this exotic species provides a pathway for biotransformation of a considerable mass of selenium into the benthic food web. The San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board developed a Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) and implementation plan for selenium in North San Francisco Bay (NSFB). The TMDL is based on attainment of water column and fish tissue target concentrations protective of human health, aquatic life, and wildlife, and was approved by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) in August 2016. A primary goal of the Selenium Workgroup is to identify leading indicators of change to allow prompt management response to signs of increasing risk of impairment. Currently, selenium is being monitored in water as well as clam and sturgeon tissue in NSFB. Selenium is also a consistent analyte for the RMP's Status and Trend monitoring work. In 2019 the selenium workgroup began a long-term monitoring project in North San Francisco Bay of water, clams, and sturgeon. The clam and water monitoring data provides a continuation of former USGS monitoring (for more information on these efforts see here and here).
The scientific advisory panel for the Bay RMP Selenium Workgroup consists of:
- Dr. Harry Ohlendorf, CH2M Hill
Lead Scientist: Jay Davis
For more information, please contact Jay Davis at: ph 510-746-7368 or [email protected]
*This workgroup is currently dormant*
At the request of the Regional Board, the RMP expanded the biological effects portion of the Status and Trends program, which at the time only monitored for aquatic and sediment toxicity. The Exposure and Effects Workgroup (EEWG) was formed with members from SFEI, USGS, AMS, the Regional Board, and other interested stakeholders. One of the purposes of the workgroup was to develop a biological effects pilot study (the Exposure and Effects Pilot Study (EEPS)) that would help address beneficial use management questions developed by the Regional Board. By building on the recommendations of other effects workgroups, reviewing existing literature related to work in the Estuary, and soliciting recommendations from the local scientific community (through a survey) the workgroup designed a five-year plan for addressing biological effects in the Bay.
The RMP’s EEPS evaluated a balanced suite of contaminant exposure and effects indicators that respond to general and specific contamination at the biochemical, cellular, individual, population, and community level. It evaluated contaminant effects and exposure in different media (on the bay floor, in the water column, and in wetlands/estuary margins), and at different spatial scales (site-specific, regionally, and estuary-wide). These initial overarching principles incorporate recommendations of the EEWG.
At the end of the five year pilot study the workgroup was incorporated into the RMP as a permanent workgroup. The EEWG continues to address the biological effects portion of the Status and Trends program and Pilot and Special Studies.
The scientific advisory panel consists of internationally known experts in this field including:
- Dr. Michael Fry, Fish and Wildlife Service - Hawaii
- Dr. Harry Ohlendorf, CH2M Hill
- Dr. Dan Schlenk, University of California – Riverside
- Dr. Steve Weisberg, Southern California Coastal Water Research Project
Lead Scientists: Jay Davis
For further information, please contact Jay Davis at: ph 510-746-7368 or [email protected].
Sediment is a critical water quality parameter for the Bay. Sediment transport is a major factor in the fate and transport of priority pollutants such as PCBs and mercury. Suspended sediment concentrations in the water are also important for preventing large algae blooms despite high nutrient concentrations.
The RMP has been studying sediment since the Program began in 1993. In recent years, sea level rise has heightened the interest in sediment supply to the Bay. The mass balance of sediment in the Bay is a critical factor for marshes and other shoreline habitats to be able to withstand the rising seas. As the San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority decides how to spend $500 million for habitat restoration, it is critical to know how much sediment will be available and where.
In 2018, the RMP created a new Sediment Workgroup to bring together key stakeholders and scientists studying this issue and to prioritize science studies to inform management decisions. There are currently no scientific advisors for the Bay RMP Sediment Strategy Workgroup.
The scientific advisory panel for the Bay RMP Sediment Workgroup consists of internationally respected experts:
- Dave Schoellhammer, USGS
- Dr. Pat Wiberg, University of Virginia
Lead Scientist: Scott Dusterhoff
For more information, please contact Scott Dusterhoff at: ph 510-746-7350 or [email protected].
Findings from a screening-level RMP study of microplastic pollution in our Bay show widespread contamination at levels greater than other U.S. water bodies with high levels of urban development, the Great Lakes and Chesapeake Bay. Wildlife consume microplastic particles; ingestion can lead to physical harm, and can expose aquatic organisms to chemical pollutants in the plastic.
In 2016, the RMP established a Microplastic Workgroup to aid in the development of a monitoring strategy and guide further study of this contamination. The scientific advisory panel for the Workgroup includes internationally respected experts:
- Anna-Marie Cook, USEPA
- Kara Lavender Law, Sea Education Association, Inc.
- Chelsea Rochman, University of Toronto
Lead Scientists: Diana Lin
THE RMP DOCUMENT ARCHIVES
This archive contains important documents relating to the establishment and development of the RMP.
Laying the Foundations: Establishing the RMP
|Carlin and Mumley. 1990. San Francisco Estuary Monitoring Program: Working Paper #1.||San Francisco Bay Water Board Resolution No. 92-043 (April 1992): Implementation of the Regional Monitoring Plan within the San Francisco Bay Region||13267 Letter (June 1992) from Water Board to Dischargers: Implementation of a Regional Monitoring Program for the San Francisco Estuary||Memorandum of Understanding Between the Water Board and AHI Concerning Implementation of the RMP (1992)|
Early RMP Reports
|Flegal et al. 1991. Trace Element Cycles in the San Francisco Bay Estuary: Results from a Preliminary Study in 1989-1990||Taberski et al. 1992. San Francisco Bay Pilot Regional Monitoring Program 1991-1992: Summary Progress Report.||
SFEI. 1994. 1993 Annual Report: San Francisco Estuary Regional Monitoring Program for Trace Substances.
The first RMP Annual Report
SFBRWQCB. 1995. Contaminant Levels in Fish Tissue from San Francisco Bay.
First report on contaminants in fish tissue, conducted in 1994 under the Bay Protection and Toxic Cleanup Program